Popper-consensus · does it know when it's wrong?

Domains — temporal-holdout benchmarks across disciplines

Each domain is a real ORKG research problem. We hold out a later "discovery" paper and give the compiler only strictly-earlier prior literature (the temporal wall). Grouped by discipline so you can see whether grounding, falsifiability, and composite stay stable across fields or whether some expose weaknesses in the schema.

biomedicine

Biomedical research in Psychiatric Disorders (biomedicine)
10 prior papers · 60 claims · held out R138825
composite0.97
grounding1.00
falsifiable1.00
rediscovery0.00
Cyclodextrin complexes to enhance drug solubilty or bioavailabilty (biomedicine)
10 prior papers · 32 claims · held out R155608
composite0.99
grounding1.00
falsifiable1.00
rediscovery0.00
experimental evolution (biomedicine)
5 prior papers · 30 claims · held out R1385771
composite0.98
grounding1.00
falsifiable1.00
rediscovery0.00

chemistry

Chemical sensors (chemistry)
10 prior papers · 60 claims · held out R140743
composite0.99
grounding1.00
falsifiable1.00
rediscovery0.00
Niobium-Based Materials for Photocatalytic Solar Fuel Production (chemistry)
10 prior papers · 51 claims · held out R46213
composite0.99
grounding1.00
falsifiable1.00
rediscovery0.20
TiO2 Photocatalysis (chemistry)
10 prior papers · 38 claims · held out R46117
composite0.98
grounding1.00
falsifiable1.00
rediscovery0.00

computer science

empirical research in requirements engineering (computer_science)
10 prior papers · 50 claims · held out R78392
composite1.00
grounding1.00
falsifiable1.00
rediscovery0.00
Image classification (computer_science)
10 prior papers · 49 claims · held out R1853074
composite0.99
grounding1.00
falsifiable1.00
rediscovery0.00
Semantic segmentation (computer_science)
10 prior papers · 57 claims · held out R1801235
composite0.99
grounding1.00
falsifiable1.00
rediscovery0.00

environmental science

Biodiversity inventories with DNA based-tools (environmental_science)
10 prior papers · 60 claims · held out R145296
composite0.99
grounding1.00
falsifiable1.00
rediscovery0.30
CMIP5 (environmental_science)
10 prior papers · 56 claims · held out R9221
composite0.97
grounding1.00
falsifiable1.00
rediscovery0.00
Global climate modelling (environmental_science)
10 prior papers · 56 claims · held out R9221
composite0.99
grounding1.00
falsifiable1.00
rediscovery0.00

materials science

Mapping dopant–host combinations in ALD thin films (materials_science)
10 prior papers · 54 claims · held out R1469826
composite0.99
grounding1.00
falsifiable1.00
rediscovery0.00
Mapping precursor chemistries used in rare-earth ALD processes (materials_science)
10 prior papers · 56 claims · held out R1470140
composite0.98
grounding1.00
falsifiable1.00
rediscovery0.00
process parameters on the performance characteristics of ALD-deposited films (materials_science)
8 prior papers · 48 claims · held out R676165
composite0.98
grounding1.00
falsifiable1.00
rediscovery0.00

neuroscience

CT Image Segmentation and Classification (neuroscience)
8 prior papers · 42 claims · held out R700939
composite0.99
grounding1.00
falsifiable1.00
rediscovery0.00
Simultaneous localization and mapping (neuroscience)
9 prior papers · 52 claims · held out R1411278
composite0.98
grounding1.00
falsifiable1.00
rediscovery0.00

physics

Dataset used in wind energy potential assessment (physics)
10 prior papers · 60 claims · held out R703055
composite0.99
grounding1.00
falsifiable1.00
rediscovery0.00
Solar radiation prediction (physics)
10 prior papers · 60 claims · held out R1563914
composite0.97
grounding1.00
falsifiable1.00
rediscovery0.00
Wind speed distributions performance analysis (physics)
10 prior papers · 60 claims · held out R709086
composite0.99
grounding1.00
falsifiable1.00
rediscovery0.00